Strike three, and you’re out!” yells a baseball or softball umpire as a batter swings at a ball and misses for the third time. This is Our text narrates an incident in the life of
the people of Israel during their wilderness pilgrimage to the Promised Land that had serious consequences for their leader Moses. After the people grumbled about their thirst, God told Moses to speak to the rock at Meribah and water will flow out of the rock. But instead of speaking to the rock, Moses struck it with his staff, not once, but twice.
Remember the first narrative about the people complaining about the lack of water in the wilderness? In Exodus 17, God told Moses to strike the rock, and Moses obeyed God’s command, so water came out of the rock and the people’s thirst was satisfied. In this second incident, God commanded Moses to speak, not strike, the rock. So there’s that big difference between the two incidents. The consequence of this action by Moses and Aaron was enormous. With two, not three, swings of his staff at the rock, Moses struck out of the Promised Land! God did not allow him and his brother Aaron to enter Canaan. This punishment seems to be very harsh and disproportional to the offense. Why would God punish Moses for one “minor” disobedience compared with his faithfulness to God throughout the wilderness wanderings? For us, this may seem like a death sentence for jaywalking.
In both of these water-from-the-rock episodes, there are two significant lessons learned by Moses and the people of Israel. First, God is holy and glorious, and honoring his name and his word is paramount. Second, faith in God is evidenced by honoring and giving glory to God. Moses struck out, not only in literally striking the rock twice but also in these two important lessons about God’s word.
So today, we will dwell on the theme, “Strike Two! And You’re Out of the Promised Land”: first, Strike One: Self-Focus; second, Strike Two: Unbelief; and third, Hope for Those Who Strike Out.
Strike One: Self-Focus
Very early in Israel’s march toward the Promised Land, they started grumbling about hardship, food, water, and even about Moses’ leadership. To Moses, it must have been very frustrating to hear the same complaints over and over again. If you were Moses, wouldn’t you be also tired and aggravated by these people, who were like little children pestering you with their tantrums?
But God did not lack in his providential care for them from the time they came out of Egypt. He protected them from Pharaoh’s army by parting the Red Sea and accompanied them on their journey with a pillar of cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night. He unfailingly provided food and
water for them. Then they camped in the Mount Sinai area, in the wilderness of Sin (not the same as the wilderness of Zin in Numbers 20). In Exodus 17:1-7, the people complained that they had no water to drink, so the Lord commanded Moses to gather the people before a rock and strike the rock. In the sight of all Israel, Moses obeyed, and God provided ample water for everyone.
But almost 40 years later, here in Numbers 20:2-13, as they were encamped at Kadesh-Barnea, the people complained again that there was no water to drink. This time, God commanded Moses to gather the people in front of a rock and command the rock to give water. But in contrast to the first incident, Moses disobeyed God’s word by striking the rock twice to make water flow from the rock.
Geological studies contribute to a possible explanation of why God commanded Moses to strike the rock in the Mount Sinai area, then to speak to the rock in the Kadesh-Barnea area. Mount Sinai area’s rocks are made out of granite—massive, heavy, hard, and tough. Today, granite is used in building construction, and it is very popular as kitchen countertops because of its toughness as well as beauty. (John A. Beck, “Why Did Moses Strike Out”? Westminster Theological Journal 65 (2003), 140.)
Why would God ask Moses to strike the rock before the people to get water out of the granite rock? They all knew that even if the whole assembly struck the rock with all their might, no water would come out of it. It was only by God’s mighty work that water came out of a granite rock at Massah.
Why then did Moses strike the rock at Meribah? The first obvious reason is that he was angry with the people. After he gathered all the congregation of Israel, Moses first gave his speech of rebuke, “Hear now, you rebels: shall we bring water for you out of this rock?” (v 10). In his anger, Moses himself judged the people. God did not ask him to rebuke and chastise them. He only commanded Moses to gather them and show them that he spoke to the rock.
We are not exempt from this. There are times when the best thing for us to do is to merely tell our family member or friend what the word of God says, and not to rebuke them. God’s word will rebuke them. But because of our anger, especially as parents or friends, we react in anger and say some words that we should not have said and later are sorry that we did. Pastors and elders at times fall into this anger. And some even voice their frustration in their preaching, lashing out at the congregation. It is good to chastise and rebuke a congregation for not being interested in evening services, Bible studies, and prayer meetings and for not giving enough out of their abundance, but not out of frustration and anger. A rebuke has to be done to the glory and honor of God’s name.
Moses was focused on himself. He was not only angry, calling the people “rebels,” but he also took credit for bringing water from the rock. From his angry words, he says he and Aaron can bring water out of the rock. We all sin when we focus on ourselves. When we’re angry, our focus is on how another person has offended us. Then it becomes very hard to forgive and forget because our feelings are hurt. We start thinking about how to get even, and then we strike back in
anger. And when we are successful, we also tend to take credit for ourselves. We become proud of our family, children, career, accomplishments, material possessions, and even our wisdom.
Not only did Moses take credit for God’s glory; but he also acted in disobedience because of unbelief just like the rest of the people.
Strike Two: Unbelief
Why did Moses strike the rock twice? Geologists have a second and not too obvious possible answer. The rocks in the area of the wilderness of Zin are commonly made of limestone, more commonly known as chalk.
Did Moses Strike Out”? 138, 140.[/ref]
Limestone is soluble in water so rain and streams slowly drain through cracks in the limestone. Over time, the cracks enlarge and fill with water. Later, the outer layer of limestone solidifies while water continues to build up behind it.
It was this kind of limestone rock that Moses faced in Numbers 20. He knew that no matter how much he yelled at the rock, no water will come out of it. Even if the whole congregation screamed at the top of their voices, water would not come out of the limestone by itself! But Moses also knew that limestone rock is weak and if he struck it at its weak points with his staff, not once but twice, the outer layer would break and there is surely plenty of water for the people to satisfy their thirst. However, God did not want the people to see that it was Moses who produced the water through his effort and knowledge. God wanted his mighty work to be displayed before the whole assembly.
When Moses struck the rock twice, it was solid evidence of his unbelief. He did not believe that God could make water flow out of the rock through a spoken word. If water did not come out of the rock, how would he then maintain the confidence of this unbelieving congregation in his leadership?
Another question frequently raised about this story is this: Was God’s punishment of Moses commensurate with his sin? The answer given in our text is a resounding yes because his sin was unbelief. In the previous chapters, we read that Israel’s unbelief and rebellion cost them the Promised Land. Because they did not believe that God would give the land to them, God prevented them from entering it.
Here, Moses was also found to be unbelieving and rebellious. It was only just and fair for God to mete out the same sentence to him as he did to the rest of the people of Israel. It was also a fulfillment of God’s vow against all the first-generation Israeli adults to prevent them from entering their rest in the Promised Land. However, never think that Moses, Aaron, and Miriam are unbelievers. They are both saints and sinners at the same time, just like all of us. Moses is revered by our Lord and even appeared with Elijah and our Lord in glory.
At Massah, they tested the Lord. At Meribah, they quarreled against the Lord. In both incidents, it was because of unbelief. Is there hope for Moses and Israel after they struck out of the Promised Land? Is there hope for us as well who continually strike out in our selfishness and unbelief?
Hope for Those Who Strike Out
God’s reaction against Israel’s unbelief and rebellion was always wrathful but was followed by grace, mercy, and forgiveness after Moses and Aaron interceded for them. In contrast, Moses reacted only in anger without grace, mercy, and forgiveness. Was there hope for them? Yes, there was, because those who honored God’s glory and trusted in his word, as Caleb, Joshua, and the second-generation Israelites did, were able to enjoy rest from their difficult wilderness pilgrimage. God fulfilled his promise to give them the land of Canaan.
Ultimately, faith in the covenant God who satisfied their thirst with water from the rock pointed forward 1,500 years later to Jesus and the Samaritan woman. “Jesus said to her, ‘Everyone who drinks of this water will be thirsty again, but whoever drinks of the water that I will give him will never be thirsty again.‚ The water that I will give him will become in him a spring of water welling up to eternal life” (John 4:13- 15). Moses as Israel’s mediator gave them water from the rock to satisfy their thirst. But Jesus gives us living water not to satisfy our parched and dry lips and mouth, but to give us eternal life.
In Exodus 17, God told Moses that he would stand before him on the rock at Sinai before Moses strikes the rock. Why did God stand before Moses and let Moses strike the rock, in effect striking God himself? It is because God himself, not Moses, will provide the life-giving water that flowed from the rock. It is this incident and Jesus’ own words that he is the living water that Paul uses as the background in 1 Corinthians 10:4, “they drank from the spiritual Rock that followed them, and the Rock was Christ.”
No, the physical rock at Massah did not follow them in their wilderness journeys, as some Jewish rabbis teach. It was their spiritual Rock, Christ himself, who followed them. God himself followed them, because he was their Rock, as the psalmist says, “The LORD is my rock and my fortress and my deliverer, my God, my rock, in whom I take refuge, my shield, and the horn of my salvation, my stronghold” (Psa 18:2).
The Rock that Moses struck twice was Christ himself! The living water that he gives us he can only give after he was struck. This is why Isaiah says, “Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows; yet we esteemed him stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted” (Isa 53:4). In his last few hours of suffering, Jesus was stripped of his clothes, flogged, spat on, struck, and pierced with a sword. This was how he was stricken, smitten, and afflicted by God so that he may give us our eternal, spiritual drink.
Why did God command Moses to strike the Rock in the first incident, and then to preach to the Rock in the second? Perhaps it is also because the two narratives are also a type of the once- for-all suffering of Christ on the cross. He needed to be stricken only once, not twice.
God is also teaching us that there is a better Mediator than Moses. Moses could not give the people Living Water. Only God could. And Moses could not accompany God’s people into the Promised Land. Only Christ could, by his provision of himself as the Living Water of eternal life.
God did not allow Moses to give Israel rest in Canaan, so that the Exodus story may again point us to Christ. Who finally gave Israel rest in the Promised Land? It was a faithful Hebrew,
Joshua, whose Greek name is Jesus, the LORD God, who will save his people from their sins (Matt 1:21). Jesus takes us to our rest in our promised land, the glorious heavenly city. In that place, we will never thirst, because Christ himself will be our River of Living Water (Rev 22:1-2).
Dear friends, when you strike out because of your selfish pride and your unbelief, do not despair or lose hope. You have a Mediator who is better than Moses. Christ is full of grace and mercy and is perfectly patient and kind. To those of you who humble yourself before him, repent of your sin and trust in him, heed Jesus’ call, “If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink. Whoever believes in me, as the Scripture has said, ‘Out of his heart will flow rivers of living water’” (John 7:37). Come to him in faith and repentance, and he will give you Living Water that will satisfy your thirst forever.
The invitation to Israel was given at Massah and Meribah. Today, the same invitation is for all of you, “The Spirit and the Bride say, Come.’ And let the one who hears say, ‘Come.’ And let the one who is thirsty come; let the one who desires take the water of life without price” (Rev 22:17). Friends, when you come to Christ the Rock and Living Water, hungering and thirsting for his righteousness, he will surely nourish and satisfy your souls forever and ever. Amen.
Rev. Nollie Malabuyo is currently pastor of Big Springs Community Church (URCNA) in Montague, California. He is the founding pastor of Zion Cornerstone Reformed Churches in Pasig (Metro Mania) and Imus, Cavite.